maybe a light at the end of the tunnel . . .
ObamaCare passed last spring and the “Stimulus” program passed back in February ’09 have become faces of excessive Government intrusion and nanny-state governance. For many of us, they are prime, number one examples of why we desire a greater majority of government decisions being pushed back down to the state and local levels.
On Monday (12-13-10), a federal district court judge in Virginia ruled that Congress “exceeded its authority” by imposing an individual mandate to purchase insurance. The website Hot Air points out the really important parts of the ruling in Virginia vs Sebelius:
“[Judge] Hudson rejected the government’s argument that it has the power under the Constitution to require individuals to buy health insurance, a provision that was set to take effect in 2014.”
Judge Hudson then wrote these two very interesting sentences:
“Of course, the same reasoning could apply to transportation, housing or nutritional decisions. This broad definition of the economic activity subject to congressional regulation lacks logical limitation”
As the folks at Hot Air were quick to point out, Judge Hudson’s two sentences described the progressive-liberal agenda and why the Constitution forbids it.
There is added significance in the ruling coming from this court as it is known as the “rocket docket” from which important cases are speedily launched to the U.S. Court of Appeals and the U.S. Supreme Court. The very backbone upon which ObamaCare is built is now rejected. This will be one to watch in the coming days and weeks ahead.
Now a moment of less dramatic impact but still insightful into the workings of our Federal Government.
For most of us, $141,000 is a good amount of pocket change (!), in fact, enough for a company to hire and pay a couple people to work.
Remember the Stimulus program passed back in February ’09? Remember how we had to quickly pass it because we had all these “shovel ready” projects just waiting to get started that would put Americans back to work? Remember how Vice President Biden was going to be the watchdog for abuse and make sure our almost 900-billion in tax dollars were spent appropriately? Remember President Obama telling us that “no one messed with Joe” [Biden]? Well, since that time, we found out just what Washington-speak for Stimulus is and it’s not pretty. One ideological wish list after another had money thrown at it. And now, we have yet another example of Stimulus money not going to produce jobs but someone’s pork project, this time at the National Science Foundation.
Here are the brief disappointing details. The National Science Foundation gave $141,000 in Stimulus funds to Montana State University to fund a six-week student trip to China to study dinosaur eggs and other fossils. Now, the trip on its own is a great experience for those students so I’m not questioning that, what I am questioning is the use of Stimulus money. How many jobs did that $141,000 Stimulate or create? I think we all know the answer and over the past two years, it’s become an all too familiar answer to Stimulus outlay after Stimulus outlay.
This is yet another example of why we need to get as much control back down to the state and local level. Trust me, if the State of Nebraska had taken state tax dollars that were meant for job creation and given it to one of the college or universities for a trip to China to study dinosaur eggs, I can guarantee you that phone lines and e-mails would be flooding into the State Capitol. It would be a very unpleasant time for state senators and the Governor and trust me, they would feel the heat. I’m very confident in saying that answers and a resolution would be forthcoming. Yet, no one in Washington seems the least bit concerned. Oh well, it’s just $141,000 no biggy. Well, here’s a dose of reality nuanced just for the elites in Washington.
This is yet another example of the complete ineptitude of the Stimulus program. Remember the Stimulus program was passed after our Democrat U.S. Senator Ben Nelson stepped in and marshaled it past a filibuster and to a successful vote in the Senate. Yet another proud moment for Cornhusker Kickback Ben which I’m sure he will make into a real snappy campaign ad in 2012 (sarcasm)!
Now there will be those that will debate that we giving tax cuts (soon I hope) and cost the treasury $800-billion over two years. I would remind everyone there is a big difference. First, Obama/Pelosi/Reid and Mr. Nelson sold the Stimulus as a job creator. Again, the phrase “shovel ready projects” was the mantra. Second, the Stimulus has cost almost one-TRILLION dollars and produced how many jobs? And don’t give me the “it saved jobs” unless you have hard numbers which no one can produce because if we are going to go down that road then the Bush tax cuts after 9-11 saved thousands upon thousands of jobs. Are Bush’s detractors willing to say that? I think hell will freeze over first and cue the song “The Sound of Silence”.
Third and most important, the Stimulus took money from you and me in the form of taxes and redistributed it throughout the country on ideological wish lists that Democrats have for decades wanted but were unable to get passed through Congress. Conversely, the tax cuts that should be approved this week, will maintain the tax rate levels that we’ve had and will NOT take additional money from tax payers rather leaving it to families across the country to spend as they see fit. I know, novel concept allowing folks to decide how they want to spend their own money but hey, call me silly, it Stimulates me.